Maybelline Sky High Mascara Review: The Drugstore Mascara That Outperforms Luxury
My honest Maybelline Sky High mascara review: the #1 drugstore mascara tested for length, volume, flaking and all-day wear. Pros, cons and who should buy it.
On this page
- Quick verdict
- The brush is the whole story
- My experience wearing it
- The pros
- The cons
- Who it is for — and who should skip it
- How Sky High fits a Christmas makeup look
- Application tips from testing
- Sky High vs my luxury mascaras — the honest scorecard
- Shade guide — Blackest Black and friends
- The three-month rule — and why it makes drugstore mascara smarter
- FAQ
- Final verdict
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you. I only review products I believe are genuinely worth it, and I always share the downsides as well as the highlights.
There is a specific frustration every mascara wearer knows: you spend real money on a luxury mascara, it is wonderful for two weeks, and then it starts flaking, clumping and giving up by lunchtime. Meanwhile a pink tube from the drugstore aisle has been sitting at the top of Amazon’s mascara best-sellers — ranked #1 in Mascara — quietly outperforming products three times its price. That tube is the Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High, and after weeks of testing it against my high-end favorites, I get it.
This review is for the Blackest Black shade, the one to reach for when you want maximum drama for party season. Here is the honest breakdown.
Quick verdict
Sky High delivers the two things most mascaras make you choose between: serious length and real volume, with a flexible brush that reaches every lash including the tiny corner ones. It lasts all day without flaking on me, removes without a fight, and costs a fraction of luxury mascaras. It has earned its #1 spot.

The brush is the whole story
Most mascara reviews talk about formula first, but Sky High’s advantage is hardware. The Flex Tower brush is slim, flexible and slightly tapered, with short bristles that grip lashes from the root. Because it bends, it follows the lash line instead of fighting it — you can wiggle it right into the base of the lashes and pull through to the tips in one motion.
That design does three things:
- Length: the formula contains bamboo extract and tiny fibers that extend the look of each lash as you pull through.
- Separation: the slim brush combs as it coats, so you get definition instead of the spidery clumps thicker brushes leave behind.
- Corners: the tapered tip reaches inner and outer corner lashes that most brushes miss, which is where the “sky high” wide-eyed effect actually comes from.
My experience wearing it
I tested Sky High the way I test every mascara: one eye with my usual luxury mascara, one eye with Sky High, full workdays, a gym session, and one long Christmas-shopping day in heated stores — the flaking Olympics.
The Sky High eye won on length clearly and matched on volume. By hour eight, the luxury side had begun to smudge faintly underneath; the Sky High side looked the same as it had at application. At hour twelve there was the smallest amount of wear at the very tips, but no panda effect and no flakes on my cheeks.
Application notes from weeks of use:
- One coat gives defined, lengthened everyday lashes.
- Two coats (applied while the first is still slightly wet) is full glam — this is my party-season setting.
- Three coats is where it starts to tip toward clumpy. Two is the sweet spot; you have been warned by someone who tested it so you don’t have to.
- It holds a curl respectably well for a non-waterproof formula, especially if you curl first and apply to dry lashes.

The pros
- Length that genuinely surprises — lashes look visibly longer, not just darker.
- The flexible brush reaches corners and lower lashes without mess.
- All-day wear — no flaking or smudging through long days in my testing.
- Removes easily with normal cleanser or micellar water — no lash-ripping waterproof removal ritual.
- Drugstore price, luxury performance — replacing it every three months (as you should with mascara) does not hurt.
The cons
- It is not waterproof. There is a waterproof version in the range; this classic formula will not survive swimming or a full crying-at-a-wedding scenario.
- The fiber formula can over-layer — past two coats, clumping begins.
- Very straight, stubborn lashes may still prefer the waterproof version for maximum curl hold.
- The tube dries out on a normal mascara timeline — expect the usual three good months, not more.
Who it is for — and who should skip it
Buy it if: you want length and volume in one tube, you are tired of paying luxury prices for mascara, you need a reliable party-season mascara that will not flake onto your party makeup, or your lashes are short and need all the help a brush can give.
Skip it if: you need genuinely waterproof wear (choose the waterproof Sky High instead), or you prefer a very natural, tint-level lash look — this one is unapologetically dramatic.

How Sky High fits a Christmas makeup look
Party makeup lives or dies on the eyes, and this mascara is the anchor of my December look: a wash of shimmer shadow, tight-lined upper lashes, two coats of Sky High, and a red or berry lip. Because it does not flake, it survives the full evening — office party at six, home at midnight, lashes intact. If you buy one makeup product for the season, the math favors the one you will use every single day of it.
Application tips from testing
- Wipe excess product off the wand tip — most clumps are born at the tip.
- Start at the very base and wiggle side to side as you pull up; the wiggle is what separates.
- Do lower lashes with the wand held vertically, using just the tip.
- Apply the second coat while the first is tacky, not fully dry.
- Keep the tube closed tightly and replace it every three months — mascara is the one product where expiry dates really matter for eye health.
Sky High vs my luxury mascaras — the honest scorecard
I own mascaras costing three to four times this one, so here is where each actually wins:
- Length: Sky High wins. The fibers plus that slim brush produce length my luxury tubes do not match.
- Volume: a draw. Luxury formulas sometimes feel plusher on the first coat; Sky High catches up on the second.
- Wear: Sky High wins on my lashes — less smudging under the eye by evening.
- Removal: Sky High wins easily. Some luxury and tubing formulas need warm water rituals or dedicated removers; this comes off with a normal cleanse.
- Prestige and packaging: luxury wins, obviously — a heavier tube feels nicer in the hand. It is also the only category that does not touch your face.
Scorecards like this are why the beauty industry is nervous about this pink tube. On every measure that affects the person looking at you, it matches or beats the expensive options.
Shade guide — Blackest Black and friends
- Blackest Black (reviewed here) — the deepest shade, for maximum contrast and evening looks. My pick for party season and for anyone with medium to deep skin tones or dark lashes.
- Very Black — a touch softer; the everyday default for fair skin or office makeup.
- Brownish Black — the natural-look option, lovely on blondes and redheads and for no-makeup makeup days.
- Colored versions (the range periodically includes burgundy and blue-black shades) — burgundy in particular makes green and hazel eyes look incredible at Christmas parties, if you catch it in stock.
The three-month rule — and why it makes drugstore mascara smarter
Mascara should be replaced every three months: the wand carries bacteria back into the tube with every use, and the formula dries and starts flaking as it ages. That replacement rhythm is simply painless at a drugstore price — and quietly expensive at luxury prices, which tempts people to stretch tubes far past their safe life. Choosing Sky High is not just a beauty decision; it is the hygienic one you will actually follow.
FAQ
Is Maybelline Sky High really the #1 mascara? It holds the #1 spot in Amazon’s Mascara category and has done so consistently — a position that reflects enormous repeat sales, which for mascara is the most honest popularity signal there is.
Sky High vs the waterproof version — which should I get? The classic (reviewed here) for everyday and events: easier removal, better layering. The waterproof for weddings, holidays and humid climates where tears and weather are real risks.
Does it work on short lashes? Yes — short lashes are arguably its best audience. The slim brush grips short lashes that fat brushes skip, and the fibers add visible length.
Is Blackest Black too harsh for fair skin? For daytime on very fair skin it is dramatic but not harsh if the rest of the makeup is soft. There is also a softer Very Black/Brownish Black option in the range for a gentler look.
Final verdict
Maybelline Sky High is the mascara I recommend when friends ask why I stopped buying luxury mascara. Length, volume, separation, all-day wear and easy removal at a drugstore price — for Christmas makeup and every day after, it is an easy yes.
Pin it for later
Loved this idea?
Save it to your Pinterest board so it is there when you need it.
← Previous post Kitsch Heatless Curling Set Review: Overnight Curls With Zero Heat Damage
Next post → Medicube PDRN Pink Peptide Serum Review: The Pink Serum All Over Your Feed
Meet the author
Beauty editor & reviewer
Ava reviews the beauty, skincare and fashion finds everyone is pinning — honest first-person takes, real pros and cons, and a straight answer on whether it is worth your money.